The content on this page is general in nature and is not legal advice because legal advice, by definition, must be specific to a particular set of facts and circumstances. No person should rely, act, or refrain from acting based upon the content of this blog post.

How to Draft a “Top-Up Option” in a Public Company Acquisition Agreement

How to Draft a “Top-Up Option” in a Public Company Acquisition Agreement

Clarifying the Purpose and Strategic Value of a Top-Up Option

In a public company acquisition structured as a tender offer followed by a merger, a top-up option is a contractual right granted by the target to the acquirer that permits the acquirer to purchase newly issued shares of the target after the tender offer closes. The objective is to increase the acquirer’s ownership percentage above a statutory threshold—historically 90 percent under certain state laws—so that the acquirer can complete a short-form merger without a shareholder vote. Although the widespread adoption of DGCL Section 251(h) has reduced the need for a 90 percent squeeze-out in Delaware, top-up options remain useful in legacy structures, in non-Delaware jurisdictions, and as a fail-safe if closing conditions limit reliance on 251(h) or a similar mechanism. Properly drafted, a top-up option reduces closing risk, shortens deal timelines, and provides transaction certainty that boards, lenders, and arbitrageurs prioritize.

However, the deceptively simple idea of issuing top-up shares hides significant complexity. The board must ensure the company has sufficient authorized but unissued shares to satisfy the option; the issuance must comply with exchange rules, blue sky exemptions, and state corporate law; and the math driving the post-exercise ownership threshold must exclude unavailable shares with precision. As both an attorney and CPA, I routinely see misunderstandings from sophisticated market participants who assume the option is boilerplate. It is not. Small numerical errors, imprecise definitions, or casual treatment of capitalization tables can derail the structure, create litigation risk, and invite regulatory scrutiny.

Determining Whether a Top-Up Option Is Necessary in Light of 251(h) and Jurisdictional Nuances

Before drafting, counsel should establish whether a short-form merger is still required to consummate the transaction. In Delaware, many tender offer deals close without a shareholder vote under Section 251(h), provided certain conditions are met, including that the offer is for all outstanding shares and the acquirer secures a statutorily sufficient number of tenders. Even where 251(h) is available, some buyers still negotiate a top-up option as an additional pathway to closing if unexpected constraints arise with offer conditions, regulatory timing, or exchange approvals. In other states, the traditional 90 percent squeeze-out threshold may still govern, making a top-up option materially important to achieving closing within the expected timeline.

One common misconception is that the availability of 251(h) renders the top-up option obsolete. In practice, transactions evolve, pre-closing events affect share counts, and tender participation by retail investors can be unpredictable. The top-up option remains a sophisticated belt-and-suspenders mechanism that can be the difference between a smooth back-end merger and a protracted, vote-based closing with heightened deal risk. Establishing the necessity at the outset frames drafting decisions concerning caps, pricing mechanics, and authorization of shares, mitigating the risk of a late-stage scramble.

Confirming Sufficient Authorized Shares and Forecasting the Capitalization Needs

At the heart of the top-up option is a precise calculation of authorized but unissued and unreserved shares. The target’s charter dictates the ceiling; the board cannot create additional authorized shares without a shareholder vote, which is rarely feasible within deal timelines. Therefore, the acquisition agreement must confirm, through representations and diligenced schedules, that enough shares exist to allow the acquirer to cross the statutory threshold after giving effect to the tender and any conversions or settlements that may occur in proximity to closing. Failing to validate this capacity early can render the top-up option illusory.

Determining sufficiency is not a simple subtraction. The capitalization schedule must carefully exclude shares reserved for employee plans, warrants, convertibles, and other derivative securities, including performance-based awards with probable vesting. It must address any shares issuable in settlement of outstanding obligations—such as deferred share units or acquisition earnouts—that could be triggered by the change in control. Accurate forecasting requires collaboration among legal, finance, and HR teams to anticipate accelerated vesting, cashout mechanics, and net share settlements. As a CPA, I underscore the need for reconciliations that tie to the transfer agent’s ledger and to board-approved equity plan reserves, not merely management spreadsheets. Miscounts of even a few percentage points can prevent the option from achieving its purpose.

Defining the Option Grant, Scope, and Term with Precision

The acquisition agreement should contain a dedicated Top-Up Option section that specifies the grant of the option, the number of shares subject to issuance, and the timeframe for exercise. The grant should be unconditional upon signing, but exercisable only after the tender offer closes and a specified minimum number of shares have been validly tendered and not withdrawn. The term is typically short—often expiring upon the earliest of consummation of the back-end merger, termination of the agreement, or a set number of business days following the offer closing. Drafting should clearly state that the option is non-assignable, exercisable by the acquirer or its designated subsidiary, and issued in book-entry form to accommodate rapid settlement.

Equally important is a well-articulated cap on issuable shares. The option should allow the acquirer to purchase only the number of shares that, together with shares already owned, will enable the consummation of the short-form merger or other intended closing mechanism. Over-issuance risks exchange rule violations and potential fiduciary duty claims. The cap should incorporate a dynamic formula tied to post-offer share counts and exclude unavailable shares, ensuring the option scales correctly with the actual tender results. Ambiguity around scope or term invites disputes at the most time-sensitive juncture of the transaction.

Crafting the Share Calculation Formula and Exclusions

The share calculation is the functional core of the top-up option. The formula should reference the fully diluted share count immediately after the tender offer settlement, expressly excluding treasury shares, shares subject to vested but unexercised options and warrants (unless to be cashed out), and shares reserved for issuance under equity plans or conversion features that will not be issued before the merger. To the extent any instruments will be settled in cash at or before the back-end closing, the drafting should state that such instruments are excluded from the denominator to avoid miscounting.

Care should be taken to handle fractional shares and rounding conventions, particularly in states requiring a precise percentage for a short-form merger. Small rounding imbalances can prevent the acquirer from crossing the statutory line. A best practice is to include a deeming provision that the number of shares issued pursuant to the option will be the minimum necessary to achieve the target ownership percentage, rounded up to the nearest whole share, subject to the global cap of authorized but unissued shares. Additionally, the formula should state that the acquirer’s percentage is calculated on a post-issuance basis to prevent circular math errors that occasionally find their way into hurriedly drafted agreements.

Setting the Exercise Price and Consideration Mechanics

The option exercise price per share typically equals the tender offer price, payable in cash, a promissory note, or a combination thereof. Many agreements allow payment with a short-term, unsecured note issued by the acquirer or a merger subsidiary, limited in recourse to the merger consideration actually payable in the back-end merger. This construct is intended to preserve liquidity while aligning the economic value of the top-up shares with the offer price and expediting the closing. If the note construct is used, the agreement should detail maturity, interest, security (if any), assignment limits, and cancellation upon consummation of the merger in exchange for the same consideration available to other shareholders.

From a practical standpoint, using a promissory note can raise accounting and legal questions. For instance, the target’s receipt of a note as consideration may affect disclosure in the target board’s recommendation statement and could prompt scrutiny from stock exchange personnel regarding whether shareholder approval rules are implicated. Although top-up issuances tied to tender offers or mergers often fit within exchange exceptions, counsel must confirm compliance in advance. Further, to mitigate claims of coercion or unfair dilution, the price mechanics should mirror the public tender price and avoid creating the appearance of a discounted insider issuance, which can fuel fiduciary duty challenges.

Addressing Corporate Law, Exchange Rules, and Securities Law Compliance

The issuance of top-up shares must comply with applicable corporate statutes, including procedural requirements around board approval, the absence of preemptive rights, and proper recording of the issuance with the transfer agent in book-entry form. The board should adopt explicit resolutions approving the issuance, reciting the consideration received, and confirming that the issuance serves a proper corporate purpose in connection with consummating the acquisition. Where charter or bylaw provisions impose constraints on issuances, those must be analyzed in diligence and addressed explicitly in the acquisition agreement’s representations and covenants.

Exchange rules can present subtle traps. Some exchanges require shareholder approval for issuances exceeding a percentage threshold, subject to exceptions for public tender offers and mergers. Counsel should confirm that the top-up issuance falls within a relevant exception and that any necessary notifications to the exchange are made in a timely manner. On the securities law front, the issuance is typically exempt from registration in the context of a merger-related transaction, but disclosure obligations remain robust. The terms of the top-up option, including pricing, caps, notes, and conditions, must be fully disclosed in tender offer documents and target board materials to reduce litigation risk and to align with best practices under antifraud rules.

Mitigating Fiduciary Duty and Appraisal Risk

Top-up options can draw allegations that directors enabled coercive tactics or engineered dilution to quell dissent. To mitigate these risks, the acquisition agreement should tie the option price to the publicly disclosed tender offer price, avoid issuing more shares than necessary to achieve the statutory objective, and ensure full and fair disclosure of mechanics and effects. The target board’s minutes should reflect a thoughtful process, reliance on financial and legal advisors, and an assessment of why the top-up serves shareholders’ best interests by reducing execution risk and accelerating payment. Where competing bidders may emerge, counsel should confirm that the option does not inappropriately impede superior proposals while preserving legitimate deal certainty for the signed buyer.

With respect to appraisal, sophisticated challengers may attempt to argue that the top-up issuance distorts valuation inputs or affects appraisal-eligible shares. The agreement should clearly provide that holders receive the same per-share consideration regardless of the top-up, and drafting must avoid any inference that the top-up was used to manipulate deal price. Furthermore, do not ignore the effect of any appraisal litigation reserves or holdbacks on merger consideration flows, especially if a promissory note is used as top-up consideration and is intended to be canceled or netted at closing. Consistency and transparency in disclosures are critical to defending process integrity.

Integrating Tax and Accounting Considerations

Although the target’s issuance of shares typically does not generate taxable gain to the issuer under general corporate tax principles, tax-sensitive mechanics still matter. The target’s acceptance of a promissory note as consideration may have financial reporting implications, including fair value measurement, and can influence the timing of revenue recognition for financial statement purposes under applicable standards. On the acquirer side, the basis in acquired shares, intercompany eliminations in post-merger consolidation, and the classification of consideration flows require careful coordination between legal and finance teams to ensure consistent reporting in the offer documents and subsequent filings.

Ownership changes triggered by the tender and top-up issuance can also impact net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes under change-in-ownership rules. If the target has material NOLs or tax credits, the acquisition agreement should require delivery of up-to-date Section 382 analyses and include covenants concerning pre-closing issuances or settlements that could shift the fully diluted share base. Failure to anticipate these tax constraints can result in unintended limitations on valuable tax assets, ultimately eroding the transaction’s expected economics.

Coordinating Closing Mechanics, Timing, and Settlement

Drafting must accommodate a tight closing timeline between the tender offer settlement and the exercise of the top-up option. The parties should pre-clear book-entry procedures with the transfer agent, establish a form of officer’s certificate for issuance, and memorialize board approvals in advance. If consideration includes a promissory note, the executed note should be held in escrow with clear instructions that automatically release it upon satisfaction of exercise conditions. The agreement should also specify that the issuance of the top-up shares will be effective immediately upon receipt of consideration and receipt of any certificates, without additional corporate action, to prevent timing gaps.

Given the compressed schedule, well-drafted covenants are essential. The target must covenant not to issue additional equity or adjust awards in a manner that would affect the denominator without the acquirer’s consent. The acquirer must covenant to promptly exercise the option when conditions are met and to provide closing funds or notes as agreed. Deliverables should include updated capitalization certificates, exchange notifications, and legal opinions if any exchange or lender requires them. Managing these mechanics with rigor prevents avoidable slippage that can jeopardize financing, hedging, and deal protection constructs.

Representations, Warranties, and Covenants Essential to a Workable Top-Up

The target should represent and warrant that it has the corporate power and authority to grant and issue the top-up shares, that the shares when issued will be duly authorized, validly issued, fully paid, and nonassessable, and that no preemptive or similar rights apply. It should also provide a detailed capitalization representation that reconciles authorized, issued and outstanding, treasury, and reserved shares, together with a schedule identifying all equity-linked instruments. The acquirer should receive a covenant that the target will reserve for issuance the maximum number of shares necessary to satisfy the option, maintain listing through the tender period, and refrain from actions that would impair issuance.

The acquirer, in turn, should represent that it has available funds or committed financing to satisfy the tender offer and the option exercise (if payable in cash), or that it has the authority to issue the agreed promissory note. A covenant to use commercially reasonable efforts to consummate the back-end merger promptly upon exercise is prudent. Both parties should include compliance representations regarding exchange rules and applicable corporate and securities laws, reducing the risk that a technical failure obstructs the closing sequence.

Common Drafting Pitfalls and Practical Solutions

Common mistakes include failing to cap the number of issuable shares; omitting an explicit exclusion for treasury and reserved shares; using a circular calculation that misstates the post-issuance ownership percentage; and neglecting to address fractional shares. Another recurring problem is assuming that a promissory note is universally acceptable consideration without confirming that the target’s charter or state law permits such consideration and that the exchange will not raise concerns. Overlooking lender covenants that restrict equity issuances or the assumption that a routine notification will suffice can similarly cause last-minute delays.

Practical solutions are straightforward but require discipline. Define the Top-Up Option in a standalone section with a precise formula that is illustrated in an annex with a worked numerical example using hypothetical tender results. Obtain a written confirmation from the transfer agent of authorized and unissued shares available, taking into account reserved amounts. Pre-clear exchange compliance positions in writing if issuance size is near a threshold. If a promissory note will be used, have treasury and accounting review the instrument well before signing, and include cancellation mechanics that cleanly net against merger consideration. These steps transform a risky provision into a reliable closing tool.

Sample Clause Concepts to Guide Drafting

While every transaction is unique, effective clauses usually include: a grant of an irrevocable option to purchase up to a specified number of newly issued shares; an exercise condition tied to the closing of the tender offer with no material breach of conditions; a per-share exercise price equal to the tender offer price; a cap limiting issuance to what is necessary to achieve the applicable short-form threshold; and an express exclusion of treasury shares, plan-reserved shares, and other unavailable securities from all calculations. The clause should also authorize book-entry issuance and acknowledge that the top-up shares will be converted in the back-end merger for the same consideration as other shares, subject to customary dissenters’ rights.

Many robust agreements also provide for payment in cash or by issuance of a promissory note in a prescribed form, limited recourse to merger consideration, automatic cancellation upon consummation, and representations from both parties regarding authority and compliance. The clause should address governing law in alignment with the merger agreement, contain a severability provision to protect the broader deal if the top-up is challenged, and include a commitment by the target to reserve and keep available the maximum number of shares subject to the option until expiration or consummation of the merger.

Due Diligence, Disclosure, and Stakeholder Communications

Effective diligence is both legal and numerical. Legal teams must review charter provisions, board resolutions, equity plans, warrant and convertible instruments, and exchange correspondence. Finance must produce a reconciled, audit-ready capitalization table reflecting all potential issuances through closing, supported by transfer agent records and award system extracts. These efforts should culminate in clean schedules to the acquisition agreement and in draft disclosure describing the top-up terms, the rationale for inclusion, and the effects on ownership percentages.

Stakeholder communications—including board presentations, tender offer documents, and employee FAQs—should explain the mechanics in plain terms without minimizing complexity. Investors and proxy advisors will be alert to perceived coercion or obfuscation. Clear disclosure that the issuance is only for the minimum number of shares needed to facilitate the merger, at the same price as the tender, helps reduce controversy. In my experience, candor and precision in disclosure are as important as the legal language itself in avoiding disputes.

Why Experienced Counsel and Integrated Tax Support Are Essential

Even seasoned deal teams can underestimate the complexity baked into a top-up option. The provision touches corporate law, securities regulation, exchange compliance, tax, accounting, transfer agency logistics, and fiduciary duty considerations. Each topic contains traps where small drafting choices create outsized risk. The cost of a misstep can be significant—ranging from delayed closings and incremental financing costs to litigation that challenges board process and alleged coercion. In short, a top-up option is not a “plug-and-play” clause. It is a bespoke instrument that must be calibrated to the transaction’s structure and the target’s capital architecture.

As an attorney and CPA, my recommendation is unequivocal: involve integrated legal and tax advisors from the earliest drafting stage. They will stress test the share math, confirm availability under the charter and exchange rules, validate consideration mechanics, and prepare disclosure that withstands scrutiny. This investment pays dividends in execution certainty. In an environment where timelines are compressed and stakeholders are unforgiving, meticulous planning and professional oversight convert a complex device into a reliable path to closing.

As the expression goes, if you think hiring a professional is expensive, wait until you hire an amateur. Do not make the costly mistake of hiring an offshore, fly-by-night, and possibly illegal online “service” to handle your legal needs. Where will they be when something goes wrong? . . . Hire an experienced attorney and CPA, knowing you are working with a credentialed professional with a brick-and-mortar office.
— Prof. Chad D. Cummings, CPA, Esq., M.S.T., LL.M., CMA, CFE, CIA, CRMA, CISA, CITP, FCPA, PFS, CFP (emphasis added)

Cummings & Cummings Law

The Redomestication Law Firm

Cummings & Cummings Law is a multi-state law practice serving businesses and their owners, with an emphasis on corporate law, business transactions, and interstate business redomiciling.

The Redomestication Law Firm, as it is known, handles more redomestications than any other law firm in the United States, having completed over 500 to date and consulted on thousands more.

When business owners contemplate transferring a company to a new state, they benefit from the firm's in-depth state-by-state guides explaining how to move a business to a new state and our state-to-state conversion blog.

We emphasize efficiency, transparent pricing, and technology-driven legal services designed to simplify complex transactions.

Our firm represents clients across the United States in federal tax matters and has attorneys licensed to practice in Florida, Oklahoma, Texas, and Wyoming.

Meet Prof. Chad D. Cummings

Attorney, CPA, and CFP

I am an attorney, Certified Public Accountant, and Certified Financial Planner serving clients in corporate and tax law matters.

Previously, I served in operations and finance with the world's largest accounting firm (PricewaterhouseCoopers), airline (American Airlines), and bank (JPMorgan Chase & Co.). I have also created and advised a variety of start-up ventures.

I am a member of The Florida Bar and the State Bar of Texas, and I hold active CPA licensure in both of those jurisdictions. I am also a member of the Wyoming State Bar.

I hold undergraduate (B.B.A.) and graduate (M.S.) degrees in accounting and taxation, respectively. I also hold the Juris Doctor (J.D.) and Master of Laws (LL.M.) degrees. I maintain a variety of other accounting, tax, and finance credentials which I apply in my law practice for the benefit of my clients.

My practice emphasizes, but is not limited to, the law as it intersects businesses and their owners.